• For users new and old: the forum rules were streamlined when we transitioned to the new software. Please ensure that you are familiar with them. Continued use of the forum means that you (a) know the rules, and (b) pledge that you'll abide by them. For more information, check out the OrthodoxChristianity.Net Rules section. (There are only 2 threads there - Rules, and Administrative Structure.)

Search results

  1. Wandile

    Papal Forgeries: A Road to Schism

    I don’t actually know his real name:ROFLMAO: Just his twitter account.
  2. Wandile

    Papal Forgeries: A Road to Schism

    I don’t think the Atahnasian creed is a forgery. It’s just Pseudepigraphic. The creed itself is ancient western symbol and captures the faith of the ancient west on the Holy Trinity quite beautifully. Many things in Christendom are falsely attributed to people mostly due piety or just some...
  3. Wandile

    Papal Forgeries: A Road to Schism

    No problem I just sent a private message to you. He has done 4 major critiques so far and plans to do more.
  4. Wandile

    Papal Forgeries: A Road to Schism

    Not at all. I was just talking about the proposed book at hand
  5. Wandile

    Papal Forgeries: A Road to Schism

    Actually the author of this book does not seem so clued up on the topic as he has been exposed on a few occasions now to have made serious blunders due to a lack of scrupulosity in fact checking alleged forgeries. This one is a case in point which was quite throughly proven to be a mistake by...
  6. Wandile

    Bishop St. Fulgentius of Ruspe on the Filioque.

    I haven’t been active on here in a long time. Since my last post actually. Please leave me alone. I have a life.
  7. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    Good thing catholics believe that a person cannot be separated from his confession. Hence it is the Catholic belief that Peter is the Rock because of his confession of faith but yes... strawman arguments need to strawman As to the second paragraph he is speaking of Apostleship as there is not...
  8. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    What a dream LOL This idea is heretical in your communion as it implies Rome is still a member (though in a terrible state) of your communion. The Catholic Church is the church of Jesus Christ. The only church that has never changed her name nor has anyone dared to strip this name from her...
  9. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    I don’t hate anything about the east. I don’t even have problems with the Eastern Orthodox purely on the basis of it being Eastern. All my objections are theological. Nothing more. The Eastern Orthodox have a habit and disagreeing with things purely because it’s western and even some Eastern...
  10. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    Their is rich coming from you. Remember how the Eastern Orthodox dogmatized a teaching based off the experiences of monks who claimed to see divine light based on certain practices which include breathing a certain way. This is literally private revelation becoming dogma in Eastern Orthodoxy...
  11. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    Most tradconsider the German contrastive contingent (Ratzinger, Muller etc) as heretics or at least suspect and the most favorable they view Benedict as is a traitor. Just busy any trad blog or site and your will see this in the first two comments of any comments section I am catholic...
  12. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    Relax. Christ’s Church is the Catholic Church.
  13. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    By conservatives, not by traditional Catholics. This is because it’s hard to shake off the influence of his youth. Remember Ratzinger was liberal in his youth and only later with age became a conservative openly admitting the errors of his youth. You do know this man was censured by the...
  14. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    I appreciate the effort but your post shows many misunderstandings of what I’m saying and what the Catholic Church teaches about the church fathers and development of doctrine. It is becoming more apparent as time passes by that almost every major hangup you have with the CC is based on some...
  15. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    You can try deflect all you want but if you believe in the real presence you can’t deny the sacred heart devotion or Eucharistic adoration with a straight face at the same time if you want to be taken seriously. There is just no two ways around it. It’s the same underlying theology in all cases.
  16. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    I’m sorry but a Catholics experience of the Eastern Orthodox attack on western customs is not limited to this forum. Secondly the fact that there even threads discussing the acceptability and validity of Eucharistic adoration are problematic enough on their own. You might as well start threads...
  17. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    Bad practice and bad belief are two different things. If an Eastern Orthodox Christian attends the highest and most aesthetically pleasing liturgy celebrated by all bishops and patriarchs but still believes that Eucharistic adoration and the sacred heart devotion are wrong; well that person has...
  18. Wandile

    Sacred Heart devotion and charges of Nestorianism

    Almost all their lives are shrouded with complete and saintly humility and they document their experiences normally on the advice of someone else like a spiritual advisor and even then it’s documented in that person’s diary and only later revealed after death. This is the normal trend so yes...
Top