• Christ is Risen!
  • Please remember: Pray for Ukraine in the Prayer forum; Share news in the Christian News section; Discuss religious implications in FFA: Religious Topics; Discuss political implications in Politics (and if you don't have access, PM me) Thank you! + Fr. George, Forum Administrator

Do Individuals Belong to Rites?

OrthoNoob

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Jun 3, 2012
Messages
1,159
Reaction score
1
Points
0
This is just a quick question, but basically:

Does an individual belong to a Rite in the way that he belongs to a "particular Church" in Catholicism? For instance, I will almost certainly be baptized in a Byzantine-Rite parish. If I move to another city and start attending a Western Rite parish, am I then considered WRO, bound by the WR fasting and prayer rules and not the BR ones, etc.? Or am I still a Byzantine just attending a Western parish until I make a formal transfer, like in the RCC?
 

mike

Protostrator
Joined
Sep 14, 2008
Messages
24,873
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
31
Location
Białystok / Warsaw
Faith
Christian
Jurisdiction
Diocese of Białystok and Gdańsk
IMO it's wise to keep fasting etc. either how it's done at the parish you attend or the one suggested by your spiritual father (if you have one). Nothing about that "rite bounding".
 

choy

Archon
Joined
Jul 11, 2012
Messages
2,316
Reaction score
0
Points
0
OrthoNoob said:
This is just a quick question, but basically:

Does an individual belong to a Rite in the way that he belongs to a "particular Church" in Catholicism? For instance, I will almost certainly be baptized in a Byzantine-Rite parish. If I move to another city and start attending a Western Rite parish, am I then considered WRO, bound by the WR fasting and prayer rules and not the BR ones, etc.? Or am I still a Byzantine just attending a Western parish until I make a formal transfer, like in the RCC?
The WR has a different Fasting routine?
 

OrthoNoob

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Jun 3, 2012
Messages
1,159
Reaction score
1
Points
0
choy said:
OrthoNoob said:
This is just a quick question, but basically:

Does an individual belong to a Rite in the way that he belongs to a "particular Church" in Catholicism? For instance, I will almost certainly be baptized in a Byzantine-Rite parish. If I move to another city and start attending a Western Rite parish, am I then considered WRO, bound by the WR fasting and prayer rules and not the BR ones, etc.? Or am I still a Byzantine just attending a Western parish until I make a formal transfer, like in the RCC?
The WR has a different Fasting routine?
It depends.

I visited the website of one WR parish and got the fasting rules they follow.

Abstinence means abstinence from meat only, with no restrictions on number, size, or timing of meals, and is practiced on Fridays.

Fasting limits the number, size, and timing of meals, but not the type of food, and is practiced on weekdays during Lent (along with abstinence), Wednesdays during Advent, and various special days (usually with abstinence).

By and large my research shows more fasting and less abstinence in the Western tradition, but no uniform rule for WRO.
 

Melodist

Archon
Joined
Dec 30, 2009
Messages
2,523
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
40
OrthoNoob said:
This is just a quick question, but basically:

Does an individual belong to a Rite in the way that he belongs to a "particular Church" in Catholicism? For instance, I will almost certainly be baptized in a Byzantine-Rite parish. If I move to another city and start attending a Western Rite parish, am I then considered WRO, bound by the WR fasting and prayer rules and not the BR ones, etc.? Or am I still a Byzantine just attending a Western parish until I make a formal transfer, like in the RCC?
Follow the advice of St Ambrose.

[quote author=http://www.catholicfiction.gadel.info/2012/02/saint-ambrose-quotes-and-sayings.html#axzz2HcjpN7KK]When I go to Rome, I fast on Saturday, but in Milan I do not. Do you also follow the custom of whatever church you attend, if you do not want to give or receive scandal. ~St. Ambrose of Milan[/quote]
 

sheenj

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Jan 31, 2012
Messages
1,429
Reaction score
1
Points
38
Age
29
Faith
Oriental Orthodox
Jurisdiction
Indian/Malankara Orthodox Church
Melodist said:
Follow the advice of St Ambrose.

[quote author=http://www.catholicfiction.gadel.info/2012/02/saint-ambrose-quotes-and-sayings.html#axzz2HcjpN7KK]When I go to Rome, I fast on Saturday, but in Milan I do not. Do you also follow the custom of whatever church you attend, if you do not want to give or receive scandal. ~St. Ambrose of Milan
[/quote]

QFT
 

Shanghaiski

Merarches
Joined
Dec 26, 2009
Messages
8,092
Reaction score
103
Points
63
Age
43
Location
Wisconsin, USA
No, no one belongs to a rite, or even to a parish. If you have one, follow the instructions of your spiritual father. Do that to which you are accustomed. The advice of St. Ambrose, it seems to me, applies not to personal private practice but when in public. If you're invited to someone's house and they're eating, eat.
 

Sleeper

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Oct 19, 2010
Messages
1,350
Reaction score
2
Points
0
Location
U.S.
OrthoNoob said:
choy said:
OrthoNoob said:
This is just a quick question, but basically:

Does an individual belong to a Rite in the way that he belongs to a "particular Church" in Catholicism? For instance, I will almost certainly be baptized in a Byzantine-Rite parish. If I move to another city and start attending a Western Rite parish, am I then considered WRO, bound by the WR fasting and prayer rules and not the BR ones, etc.? Or am I still a Byzantine just attending a Western parish until I make a formal transfer, like in the RCC?
The WR has a different Fasting routine?
It depends.

I visited the website of one WR parish and got the fasting rules they follow.

Abstinence means abstinence from meat only, with no restrictions on number, size, or timing of meals, and is practiced on Fridays.

Fasting limits the number, size, and timing of meals, but not the type of food, and is practiced on weekdays during Lent (along with abstinence), Wednesdays during Advent, and various special days (usually with abstinence).

By and large my research shows more fasting and less abstinence in the Western tradition, but no uniform rule for WRO.
The fasting rules for Antioch have changed, effective this liturgical year. It is much closer to the Byzantine Rite and is based on 9th century Western fasting rules. Basically, there are no differences between fasting days and abstinence days like their used to be. Every fast day is also an abstinence day, meaning one must watch the particular food they eat, as well as how much. This is typically one full meal a day, taken after noon. This now includes Mondays during Advent, and will apply to all days of Lent, except Sundays.

As for the OP question, for Antiochians, the establishing edict says:

There can be no transference from one rite to another without special dispensation. Such dispensations shall be granted only to: (a) the faithful of one rite who permanently dwell in the parochial limits of another rite and have no church of their own rite to attend; (b) to Priests appointed for specific missionary duties; otherwise there shall be no "bi-ritual" privileges for any cleric of the Archdiocese; and (c) to women who marry men of another rite automatically join the husband's rite.

I do not know if adjustments have been made to this or if this is fully enforced or not.
 

Joseph Hazen

Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
160
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Sleeper said:
OrthoNoob said:
choy said:
OrthoNoob said:
This is just a quick question, but basically:

Does an individual belong to a Rite in the way that he belongs to a "particular Church" in Catholicism? For instance, I will almost certainly be baptized in a Byzantine-Rite parish. If I move to another city and start attending a Western Rite parish, am I then considered WRO, bound by the WR fasting and prayer rules and not the BR ones, etc.? Or am I still a Byzantine just attending a Western parish until I make a formal transfer, like in the RCC?
The WR has a different Fasting routine?
It depends.

I visited the website of one WR parish and got the fasting rules they follow.

Abstinence means abstinence from meat only, with no restrictions on number, size, or timing of meals, and is practiced on Fridays.

Fasting limits the number, size, and timing of meals, but not the type of food, and is practiced on weekdays during Lent (along with abstinence), Wednesdays during Advent, and various special days (usually with abstinence).

By and large my research shows more fasting and less abstinence in the Western tradition, but no uniform rule for WRO.
The fasting rules for Antioch have changed, effective this liturgical year. It is much closer to the Byzantine Rite and is based on 9th century Western fasting rules. Basically, there are no differences between fasting days and abstinence days like their used to be. Every fast day is also an abstinence day, meaning one must watch the particular food they eat, as well as how much. This is typically one full meal a day, taken after noon. This now includes Mondays during Advent, and will apply to all days of Lent, except Sundays.

As for the OP question, for Antiochians, the establishing edict says:

There can be no transference from one rite to another without special dispensation. Such dispensations shall be granted only to: (a) the faithful of one rite who permanently dwell in the parochial limits of another rite and have no church of their own rite to attend; (b) to Priests appointed for specific missionary duties; otherwise there shall be no "bi-ritual" privileges for any cleric of the Archdiocese; and (c) to women who marry men of another rite automatically join the husband's rite.

I do not know if adjustments have been made to this or if this is fully enforced or not.
No offense to Antiochian individuals, but this is asinine and a step backwards as regards ethnocentrism. Rome does this type of thing, and ever since I really looked at it I've thought it racist. If I lived in a town with a Western and Eastern parish I shouldn't go back and forth every other Sunday, but I also am not 'bound' by which parish I attend any more than I'm 'bound' to stay Serbian just because I was Chrismated Serbian. Orthodox is Orthodox!

My wife was Chrismated Western Orthodox. We still have some Western practices because of it, and I've attended her old Western Rite parish with her when we visit the area. She is not bound by Western praxis though.

You should follow the practices of the parish you attend. That's always been the way before.

(of course clergy is a different story)
 

rakovsky

Toumarches
Joined
Aug 17, 2006
Messages
12,661
Reaction score
224
Points
63
Location
USA
Website
rakovskii.livejournal.com
Faith
Christian
Jurisdiction
Orthodox Church in America
Sleeper said:
The fasting rules for Antioch have changed, effective this liturgical year. It is much closer to the Byzantine Rite and is based on 9th century Western fasting rules. Basically, there are no differences between fasting days and abstinence days like their used to be. Every fast day is also an abstinence day, meaning one must watch the particular food they eat, as well as how much. This is typically one full meal a day, taken after noon. This now includes Mondays during Advent, and will apply to all days of Lent, except Sundays.

As for the OP question, for Antiochians, the establishing edict says:

There can be no transference from one rite to another without special dispensation. Such dispensations shall be granted only to: (a) the faithful of one rite who permanently dwell in the parochial limits of another rite and have no church of their own rite to attend; (b) to Priests appointed for specific missionary duties; otherwise there shall be no "bi-ritual" privileges for any cleric of the Archdiocese; and (c) to women who marry men of another rite automatically join the husband's rite.

I do not know if adjustments have been made to this or if this is fully enforced or not.
This seems confusing. It seems it would depend alot on how they define "rite" The only time I've heard of a separate "rite" being set up in Orthodoxy is the Western Rite done by Antiochians. No one in Orthodoxy I remember talking about dividing "Russian Rite" and "Greek Rite", although priests talk about the ways Russians and Greeks do things different in secondary customary details, the most obvious being Church Slavic vs. Biblical Greek.
 

mike

Protostrator
Joined
Sep 14, 2008
Messages
24,873
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
31
Location
Białystok / Warsaw
Faith
Christian
Jurisdiction
Diocese of Białystok and Gdańsk
Shanghaiski said:
No, no one belongs to a rite, or even to a parish.
I would disagree with "not belonging to a parish".
 

Shanghaiski

Merarches
Joined
Dec 26, 2009
Messages
8,092
Reaction score
103
Points
63
Age
43
Location
Wisconsin, USA
Michał Kalina said:
Shanghaiski said:
No, no one belongs to a rite, or even to a parish.
I would disagree with "not belonging to a parish".
It just seems to me that the concept of parish membership is neither universal nor essential.
 
Top