JamesRottnek
Taxiarches
Also, I'd much prefer to belong to the kind of church that Mor's photos depict, than I would to a church whose monks get into fist-fights every Pascha, and whose priests and monks support violence against gay people.
If the Anglican position was sensible, it would not take so long while you have repeatedly posted on other topics. Instead, it could be summed up in two paragraphs, like I have to the contrary:JamesRottnek said:I will, I keep meaning to. But I want to wait until I have time to craft a truly thoughtful response.rakovsky said:James, when you get a chance I would love to continue our discussion on the Articles of Religion on whether the Eucharistic bread actually is or contains Jesus' body.
And here's the evidence that you don't want an actual discussion.rakovsky said:If the Anglican position was sensible, it would not take so long while you have repeatedly posted on other topics. Instead, it could be summed up in two paragraphs, like I have to the contrary:JamesRottnek said:I will, I keep meaning to. But I want to wait until I have time to craft a truly thoughtful response.rakovsky said:James, when you get a chance I would love to continue our discussion on the Articles of Religion on whether the Eucharistic bread actually is or contains Jesus' body.
I would like to have an actual discussion, because it's a quite interesting and curious topic. Anglicans emphasize tradition and ecclesiastical hierarchy and sacraments and priesthood and sometimes ritual more than any other protestants, including Lutherans. And yet on the crucial question of the Eucharistic presence, most of them at their founding period in the 16th c. took the Calvinist position and the COE imposed art 29 as a requirement for its clergy.JamesRottnek said:And here's the evidence that you don't want an actual discussion.rakovsky said:If the Anglican position was sensible, it would not take so long while you have repeatedly posted on other topics. Instead, it could be summed up in two paragraphs, like I have to the contrary:JamesRottnek said:I will, I keep meaning to. But I want to wait until I have time to craft a truly thoughtful response.rakovsky said:James, when you get a chance I would love to continue our discussion on the Articles of Religion on whether the Eucharistic bread actually is or contains Jesus' body.
Yes I'm talking about the situation in the U.S. , yet people from the Middle East told me that the E.O.' and O.O.' are starting to talk, and in some cases even allow mix marriages, due to the deadly situation on the ground.JamesRottnek said:Are you primarily talking to Orthodox in the US? Because if so, I'd agree. Most of them seem to support reunion between the EO and OO. But, I'm not so certain that holds elsewhere.seekeroftruth777 said:Among Old Calendarists, and hardliners on Mount Athos, that a possibility. But most Orthodox priests and laity I talk to, don't oppose any talks with the O.O.'S as much as they oppose any talks with Protestants and Catholics. For example the Copts are very close to us, while the transgender Episcopalians with liturgical mishaps, not so much.JamesRottnek said:And yet, from the stand point of your church, they are sects. And a great many in your church think they hold heretical dogmas and theology (such as a large number of those on Mt. Athos).seekeroftruth777 said:No, but the Oriental Orthodox are a lot closer to our Orthodox Christian faith, and traditions than Evangelicalism ever could be.JamesRottnek said:You say you're GOARCH. You are aware that the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Ethiopian Orthodox Church are not in communion, right?seekeroftruth777 said:#1- These are not quote "Christians" they are sects, they hold heretical dogmas, and theology, so I don't see where you would be protecting Christians, in your fantasy scenario.Rohzek said:Who cares what sort of cheap shot the article takes at the Ethiopian Orthodox Church? It's just words. Shrug it off. As for what the Muslims who were so upset, here's what should happen. The central government sends in the police or military to protect the Christians who are only speaking their mind. If a Muslim still wants to rage hardcore to the point of burning down churches or killing people, then either arrest the violent Muslims or mow them down.seekeroftruth777 said:Would you rather the enraged Muslims kill these girls? BTW if this story had nothing to do with the Ethiopian Orthodox Church, then why did the article take a cheap shot at it? No agenda, right?Rohzek said:Maybe if the Orthodox priests and parents weren't so terrible at their job then the children they helped raise wouldn't be seduced by Evangelicals. Sounds like their problem, not the problem of the girls. Get gud son. Imprisoning people for speaking their mind is a laughable thing to do.Antonious Nikolas said:Most of what you post - most especially your photographic contributions to the "What Does Everyone Look Like" thread - is nausea inducing. You don't hear me crying about it.mike said:And that came after I had started to think you are one of the few posters of your religion whose posts I can read without gagging.
I'll let you figure that out, bright boy.mike said:Unless that was sarcastic.
I didn't say the teenagers were personally undermining the Church in this particular instance. I said the sect they belong to, similar organizations, and the website posting the news (which notably took a gratuitous potshot at the EOTC) were. Orthodox Christians are usually their primary targets, not Muslims. Protestant sects seeking to convert Orthodox Christians in Ethiopia and elsewhere and spread their own vile beliefs - as these sects are - are doing Satan's work, inadvertently or not.rakovsky said:Can you say a bit how the teenagers were undermining the Ethiopian church?
I can see it now though. Jesus comes back. Sees some Protestants preaching to his Orthodox flock. He immediately reaches for a nightstick whacks them over the head, cuffs them, and throws 'em in jail. Very Jesus. Much holy. Your image of the Lord is awe inspiring.
And as to the Episcopalians being whatever you and Mor think they are, what relevance does that have to anything? The fact remains that your church and Mor's are not in communion with one another.
The fist fights are embarrassing, they don't happen every pascha, it is the burial site of Christ, so things can get tense. The vast majority of priests, and monks don't condone violence against Homosexuals, those that do should think about how they word what they say in some parts of the world. At least we don't condone the slaughter of babies before they are even baptized, and attack the sacrament of Marriage, in the name of "tolerance"of course.JamesRottnek said:Also, I'd much prefer to belong to the kind of church that Mor's photos depict, than I would to a church whose monks get into fist-fights every Pascha, and whose priests and monks support violence against gay people.
Do you, at the very least, see how language like this suggests you don't actually want a conversation?rakovsky said:If you have intense difficulty in laying out your views, it's better to put them in a 2 paragraph summary than not at all.
It wasn't that long ago that the "Supreme Governors of the Church of England" and their pious subjects were actively pursuing a centuries long program of systematically raping and pillaging Africa, Asia, etc. Monks fighting in Jerusalem leads to some riotous Youtube videos and maybe some visits to the ER or the local police station. The world is still reeling from the after-effects of the damage your Church inflicted on the world.JamesRottnek said:Also, I'd much prefer to belong to the kind of church that Mor's photos depict, than I would to a church whose monks get into fist-fights every Pascha, and whose priests and monks support violence against gay people.
Meh Greeks got them elbows, I guess we shall see on the next roundMor Ephrem said:It wasn't that long ago that the "Supreme Governors of the Church of England" and their pious subjects were actively pursuing a centuries long program of systematically raping and pillaging Africa, Asia, etc. Monks fighting in Jerusalem leads to some riotous Youtube videos and maybe some visits to the ER or the local police station. The world is still reeling from the after-effects of the damage your Church inflicted on the world.JamesRottnek said:Also, I'd much prefer to belong to the kind of church that Mor's photos depict, than I would to a church whose monks get into fist-fights every Pascha, and whose priests and monks support violence against gay people.
I'll take the fighting monks. My money is always on the Armenians.
Aye, the Armenians always look like they could kick my posterior, to the accompaniement of excredingly dissonant military music by the noted Soviet-Armenian composer Vartan Barsegian.Mor Ephrem said:It wasn't that long ago that the "Supreme Governors of the Church of England" and their pious subjects were actively pursuing a centuries long program of systematically raping and pillaging Africa, Asia, etc. Monks fighting in Jerusalem leads to some riotous Youtube videos and maybe some visits to the ER or the local police station. The world is still reeling from the after-effects of the damage your Church inflicted on the world.JamesRottnek said:Also, I'd much prefer to belong to the kind of church that Mor's photos depict, than I would to a church whose monks get into fist-fights every Pascha, and whose priests and monks support violence against gay people.
I'll take the fighting monks. My money is always on the Armenians.
Never quit this forum.wgw said:Aye, the Armenians always look like they could kick my posterior, to the accompaniement of excredingly dissonant military music by the noted Soviet-Armenian composer Vartan Barsegian.
They might be a schismatic body, but they are Orthodox insofar as they claim that they are and work toward reunion with the Church. That's the will of Christ, that all might be one. (John 17:21) Not that all might be between 23,000 and 45,000 different denominations with different theologies, doctrines, dogmas, teachings and practices. So, I am more inclined to defend their communion, which is at the very least apostolic in origin, than a heretical made-up-from-thin-air Protestant sect which denies the very Church which canonized and wrote the Bible, and the Bible itself which says that it is not the only source of Christian faith and tradition. (2 Thess. 2:15)JamesRottnek said:And yet, from the stand point of your church, they are sects. And a great many in your church think they hold heretical dogmas and theology (such as a large number of those on Mt. Athos).seekeroftruth777 said:No, but the Oriental Orthodox are a lot closer to our Orthodox Christian faith, and traditions than Evangelicalism ever could be.JamesRottnek said:You say you're GOARCH. You are aware that the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Ethiopian Orthodox Church are not in communion, right?seekeroftruth777 said:#1- These are not quote "Christians" they are sects, they hold heretical dogmas, and theology, so I don't see where you would be protecting Christians, in your fantasy scenario.Rohzek said:Who cares what sort of cheap shot the article takes at the Ethiopian Orthodox Church? It's just words. Shrug it off. As for what the Muslims who were so upset, here's what should happen. The central government sends in the police or military to protect the Christians who are only speaking their mind. If a Muslim still wants to rage hardcore to the point of burning down churches or killing people, then either arrest the violent Muslims or mow them down.seekeroftruth777 said:Would you rather the enraged Muslims kill these girls? BTW if this story had nothing to do with the Ethiopian Orthodox Church, then why did the article take a cheap shot at it? No agenda, right?Rohzek said:Maybe if the Orthodox priests and parents weren't so terrible at their job then the children they helped raise wouldn't be seduced by Evangelicals. Sounds like their problem, not the problem of the girls. Get gud son. Imprisoning people for speaking their mind is a laughable thing to do.Antonious Nikolas said:Most of what you post - most especially your photographic contributions to the "What Does Everyone Look Like" thread - is nausea inducing. You don't hear me crying about it.mike said:And that came after I had started to think you are one of the few posters of your religion whose posts I can read without gagging.
I'll let you figure that out, bright boy.mike said:Unless that was sarcastic.
I didn't say the teenagers were personally undermining the Church in this particular instance. I said the sect they belong to, similar organizations, and the website posting the news (which notably took a gratuitous potshot at the EOTC) were. Orthodox Christians are usually their primary targets, not Muslims. Protestant sects seeking to convert Orthodox Christians in Ethiopia and elsewhere and spread their own vile beliefs - as these sects are - are doing Satan's work, inadvertently or not.rakovsky said:Can you say a bit how the teenagers were undermining the Ethiopian church?
I can see it now though. Jesus comes back. Sees some Protestants preaching to his Orthodox flock. He immediately reaches for a nightstick whacks them over the head, cuffs them, and throws 'em in jail. Very Jesus. Much holy. Your image of the Lord is awe inspiring.
Wait, James doesn't confess the Lord's body? Then why are you even having this conversation. Those that don't confess the Lord's body are not Christians.rakovsky said:James, when you get a chance I would love to continue our discussion on the Articles of Religion on whether the Eucharistic bread actually is or contains Jesus' body.
The COE's Articles of Religion , art. 28 to 29, denies what we call the Real Presence, according to the EP's Thyateira confession's correct reading of it. However, the COE only demands that its clergy profess the Articles as Truth, not laity. Typically about 80% of Anglican laity will then claim that the Articles are true and then make an interpretation of the articles 28 to 29 that matches whatever their own beliefs happen to be.xOrthodox4Christx said:Wait, James doesn't confess the Lord's body? Then why are you even having this conversation. Those that don't confess the Lord's body are not Christians.rakovsky said:James, when you get a chance I would love to continue our discussion on the Articles of Religion on whether the Eucharistic bread actually is or contains Jesus' body.
How about the Crimea war, which was fought by Britain to keep Russia from freeing the orthodox ukraine, Balkans and Crimea from the Turks?seekeroftruth777 said:MOR is right, I actually agree with him, for a change, the after effects of the Church of England imperialism is still being felt in much of the world, especially Africa, Asia, and Middle East.
If you want to talk apostolic, like talk St. Basil. In his great letter in which he differentiates schism from heresy, referring to the Holy Spirit among schismatics he says: for it ceased to be imparted when the continuity was broken.xOrthodox4Christx said:They might be a schismatic body, but they are Orthodox insofar as they claim that they are and work toward reunion with the Church. That's the will of Christ, that all might be one. (John 17:21) Not that all might be between 23,000 and 45,000 different denominations with different theologies, doctrines, dogmas, teachings and practices. So, I am more inclined to defend their communion, which is at the very least apostolic in origin, than a heretical made-up-from-thin-air Protestant sect which denies the very Church which canonized and wrote the Bible, and the Bible itself which says that it is not the only source of Christian faith and tradition. (2 Thess. 2:15)JamesRottnek said:And yet, from the stand point of your church, they are sects. And a great many in your church think they hold heretical dogmas and theology (such as a large number of those on Mt. Athos).seekeroftruth777 said:No, but the Oriental Orthodox are a lot closer to our Orthodox Christian faith, and traditions than Evangelicalism ever could be.JamesRottnek said:You say you're GOARCH. You are aware that the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Ethiopian Orthodox Church are not in communion, right?seekeroftruth777 said:#1- These are not quote "Christians" they are sects, they hold heretical dogmas, and theology, so I don't see where you would be protecting Christians, in your fantasy scenario.Rohzek said:Who cares what sort of cheap shot the article takes at the Ethiopian Orthodox Church? It's just words. Shrug it off. As for what the Muslims who were so upset, here's what should happen. The central government sends in the police or military to protect the Christians who are only speaking their mind. If a Muslim still wants to rage hardcore to the point of burning down churches or killing people, then either arrest the violent Muslims or mow them down.seekeroftruth777 said:Would you rather the enraged Muslims kill these girls? BTW if this story had nothing to do with the Ethiopian Orthodox Church, then why did the article take a cheap shot at it? No agenda, right?Rohzek said:Maybe if the Orthodox priests and parents weren't so terrible at their job then the children they helped raise wouldn't be seduced by Evangelicals. Sounds like their problem, not the problem of the girls. Get gud son. Imprisoning people for speaking their mind is a laughable thing to do.Antonious Nikolas said:Most of what you post - most especially your photographic contributions to the "What Does Everyone Look Like" thread - is nausea inducing. You don't hear me crying about it.mike said:And that came after I had started to think you are one of the few posters of your religion whose posts I can read without gagging.
I'll let you figure that out, bright boy.mike said:Unless that was sarcastic.
I didn't say the teenagers were personally undermining the Church in this particular instance. I said the sect they belong to, similar organizations, and the website posting the news (which notably took a gratuitous potshot at the EOTC) were. Orthodox Christians are usually their primary targets, not Muslims. Protestant sects seeking to convert Orthodox Christians in Ethiopia and elsewhere and spread their own vile beliefs - as these sects are - are doing Satan's work, inadvertently or not.rakovsky said:Can you say a bit how the teenagers were undermining the Ethiopian church?
I can see it now though. Jesus comes back. Sees some Protestants preaching to his Orthodox flock. He immediately reaches for a nightstick whacks them over the head, cuffs them, and throws 'em in jail. Very Jesus. Much holy. Your image of the Lord is awe inspiring.
I've pointed out a number of times to rakovsky that I have literally never met any Anglican clergy who do not confess the Lord's body in the Eucharist. And I am in agreement with them.xOrthodox4Christx said:Wait, James doesn't confess the Lord's body? Then why are you even having this conversation. Those that don't confess the Lord's body are not Christians.rakovsky said:James, when you get a chance I would love to continue our discussion on the Articles of Religion on whether the Eucharistic bread actually is or contains Jesus' body.
Or the ceaseless persecution of the non-Chalcedonians by the Byzantine Orthodox empire.rakovsky said:How about the Crimea war, which was fought by Britain to keep Russia from freeing the orthodox ukraine, Balkans and Crimea from the Turks?seekeroftruth777 said:MOR is right, I actually agree with him, for a change, the after effects of the Church of England imperialism is still being felt in much of the world, especially Africa, Asia, and Middle East.
Uh, yeah I said that. They are out of communion due to their wrongheaded schism against Chalcedon, but they profess they are Orthodox and that they want communion with us. I'm open to that possibility.JamesRottnek said:If you want to talk apostolic, like talk St. Basil. In his great letter in which he differentiates schism from heresy, referring to the Holy Spirit among schismatics he says: for it ceased to be imparted when the continuity was broken.xOrthodox4Christx said:They might be a schismatic body, but they are Orthodox insofar as they claim that they are and work toward reunion with the Church. That's the will of Christ, that all might be one. (John 17:21) Not that all might be between 23,000 and 45,000 different denominations with different theologies, doctrines, dogmas, teachings and practices. So, I am more inclined to defend their communion, which is at the very least apostolic in origin, than a heretical made-up-from-thin-air Protestant sect which denies the very Church which canonized and wrote the Bible, and the Bible itself which says that it is not the only source of Christian faith and tradition. (2 Thess. 2:15)JamesRottnek said:And yet, from the stand point of your church, they are sects. And a great many in your church think they hold heretical dogmas and theology (such as a large number of those on Mt. Athos).seekeroftruth777 said:No, but the Oriental Orthodox are a lot closer to our Orthodox Christian faith, and traditions than Evangelicalism ever could be.JamesRottnek said:You say you're GOARCH. You are aware that the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Ethiopian Orthodox Church are not in communion, right?seekeroftruth777 said:#1- These are not quote "Christians" they are sects, they hold heretical dogmas, and theology, so I don't see where you would be protecting Christians, in your fantasy scenario.Rohzek said:Who cares what sort of cheap shot the article takes at the Ethiopian Orthodox Church? It's just words. Shrug it off. As for what the Muslims who were so upset, here's what should happen. The central government sends in the police or military to protect the Christians who are only speaking their mind. If a Muslim still wants to rage hardcore to the point of burning down churches or killing people, then either arrest the violent Muslims or mow them down.seekeroftruth777 said:Would you rather the enraged Muslims kill these girls? BTW if this story had nothing to do with the Ethiopian Orthodox Church, then why did the article take a cheap shot at it? No agenda, right?Rohzek said:Maybe if the Orthodox priests and parents weren't so terrible at their job then the children they helped raise wouldn't be seduced by Evangelicals. Sounds like their problem, not the problem of the girls. Get gud son. Imprisoning people for speaking their mind is a laughable thing to do.Antonious Nikolas said:Most of what you post - most especially your photographic contributions to the "What Does Everyone Look Like" thread - is nausea inducing. You don't hear me crying about it.mike said:And that came after I had started to think you are one of the few posters of your religion whose posts I can read without gagging.
I'll let you figure that out, bright boy.mike said:Unless that was sarcastic.
I didn't say the teenagers were personally undermining the Church in this particular instance. I said the sect they belong to, similar organizations, and the website posting the news (which notably took a gratuitous potshot at the EOTC) were. Orthodox Christians are usually their primary targets, not Muslims. Protestant sects seeking to convert Orthodox Christians in Ethiopia and elsewhere and spread their own vile beliefs - as these sects are - are doing Satan's work, inadvertently or not.rakovsky said:Can you say a bit how the teenagers were undermining the Ethiopian church?
I can see it now though. Jesus comes back. Sees some Protestants preaching to his Orthodox flock. He immediately reaches for a nightstick whacks them over the head, cuffs them, and throws 'em in jail. Very Jesus. Much holy. Your image of the Lord is awe inspiring.
Or you could look at the Council of Carthage, where such eminent people as Cyril essentially eliminated the distinction between heresy and schism (in practical effect, that is). And I'd point out that your clergy and the clergy of the Oriental Orthodox still don't con-celebrate the Eucharist. They are literally out of communion with one another.
It ceased when the Islamic jihadists and Latin crusaders conquered Constantinople.JamesRottnek said:Or the ceaseless persecution of the non-Chalcedonians by the Byzantine Orthodox empire.rakovsky said:How about the Crimea war, which was fought by Britain to keep Russia from freeing the orthodox ukraine, Balkans and Crimea from the Turks?seekeroftruth777 said:MOR is right, I actually agree with him, for a change, the after effects of the Church of England imperialism is still being felt in much of the world, especially Africa, Asia, and Middle East.
The two questions I would raise here areJamesRottnek said:I've pointed out a number of times to rakovsky that I have literally never met any Anglican clergy who do not confess the Lord's body in the Eucharist. And I am in agreement with them.xOrthodox4Christx said:Wait, James doesn't confess the Lord's body? Then why are you even having this conversation. Those that don't confess the Lord's body are not Christians.rakovsky said:James, when you get a chance I would love to continue our discussion on the Articles of Religion on whether the Eucharistic bread actually is or contains Jesus' body.
Identity politics is boring. Both are crazy.JamesRottnek said:Also, I'd much prefer to belong to the kind of church that Mor's photos depict, than I would to a church whose monks get into fist-fights every Pascha, and whose priests and monks support violence against gay people.
I agree with you.Antonious Nikolas said:Of course they will. Undermining the only true Church of Ethiopia - not Islam - is the primary goal of satanic Evangelical and Charismatic sects operating in Ethiopia and their American and European backers. May God bring their vile machinations to naught and bring these girls to His truth. If they left the Orthodox Church for non-Christian cults like the MKC and the FGC, earthly prison is the least of their worries.seekeroftruth777 said:BTW leave to a evangelical online newspaper to bash the Ethiopian Orthodox Church, when it didn't do anything this time.
Well observed! We've known that their true target was the Church since the godless Derg opened the door for them and the Muslims (two sides of the same coin) in order to erode the Church's influence. When it comes to Ethiopia and Eritrea, the P'ent'ays have the West and the Muslims have Saudi Arabia, but the Orthodox have no one but God to support them. And if the local governments should step up, they are accused of all manner of evil by the enemies of Christ. May the God-fearing Emperor Fasilides - who expelled the Jesuits from Ethiopia and reversed their gains among the people - intercede for his nation at the Throne of God.Balthasar said:I agree with you.
In its anual "Christian Persecution Index", The protestant organization "OpenDoors" places Orthodox Christian nations like Ethiopia (Eritrea) way higher than notorious for Christians countries like Turkey, Algeria, Egypt, UAE, Kuwait, Bahrain and co. And non-traditional-Christian North Korea is always numero uno -- just not to embarass Muslim nations.
https://www.opendoorsusa.org/christian-persecution/world-watch-list/
Balthasar said:Anyways, the coming bloody battle will be waged between children of Ishmael and Luther.