Antonious Nikolas said:
CoptoGeek said:
Just beautiful!
"His Holiness Moran Mar Baselios Marthoma Paulos II rejoices as members of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church sing Hymns from the Prayers of Sh'himo in Malayalam"
https://www.facebook.com/876941899025885/videos/1482525275134208/?hc_ref=ARRFPX9dlE_ZpGM-47cFytYPd7Wy6cUBcCY8FGJFGyjh21Np2GPA3ZJIYCVt7pU6EnI
Very nice. My prayer is that this will enkindle a desire within the heart of His Holiness to do away with keyboards in the Indian Orthodox Church.
The best part of St. Ephrems Cathedral and my current parish is no keyboard.
I am of the opinion however that keyboards are already uncaonical; the 1920 Patriarchal decision authorizing organs implied pipe ortans, and says nothing about electronic musical synthesizers. That said, I can't think of a good use for pipe organs either in our chant; the only Orthodox music that uses it in a way I like is the polyphonic Greek Orthodox music of Tikey Zes, which I get a lot of flak for, but I love his work. So if a total ban on organs was needed to rid us from the keyboard, I couldn't possibly object, since we've in nearly a century failed to do anything with the organs other than massacre the Qurbana. If some Syriac composer had composed a series of grand epilogues to be played after the hymn Haw Nurone, when communion is taking longer than usual to distribute, some epic work on the level of Bach that would flow naturally from Haw Nurone and enliven an otherwise prologued silence, which exists because we either lack or do not use a rich repetoire of communion hymns such as those of the Coptic Church (at my old parish of St, Michaels, with just one Abuna, communion took 45 minutes, but the Psaltis had enough material after Psalm 150 to sing the entire time), that would be another matter.
Instead we have idiotic people accompanying the naturally a capella chant with squishy sounds, the "marimba" setting on the keyboard, and all sorts of other cacaphonies you can summon thanks to the devilish fruits of the Yamaha company. I loathe keyboards in churhc and everything they stand for.
~
As an aside, my great grandmother left an endowment to the UMC parish I attended in my youth to be used to purchase a pipe organ. Instead, they bought a Clavinova, which sounded like trash from day one, and spent the rest replacing the flooring and installing a stage in the parish hall, which was never once used, ever. Then, they got rid of the keyboard and switched to the drums and electronic guitar, going full wannabe rock band. The nadir was a midsummer service with a surfboard on the altar and the cobbled together copyright-infringeing trainwreck of "Worship USA" to the tune of the Beach Boys sound. I tried to escape by going to a service with traditional hymns, but the minister turned out to be an Arian homosexual; then I tried an episcopal parish with a traditionalist priest and a said service, but their "eucharist" made me sick, and then I became Syriac Orthodox after visiting the various members of the Antiochene family of churches. Although for a while I attended a Coptic parish, and before that, what I thought was a ROCOR parish, which were closer to my old house, but I fled that parish for the Coptic parish when I discovered they were ... non-canonical extremists.