• Please remember: Pray for Ukraine in the Prayer forum; Share news in the Christian News section; Discuss religious implications in FFA: Religious Topics; Discuss political implications in Politics (and if you don't have access, PM me) Thank you! + Fr. George, Forum Administrator

Peter the Rock

Status
Not open for further replies.

Aristocles

Merarches
Joined
Apr 23, 2003
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
1
Points
0
Location
Pittsburgh
carpo-rusyn said:
Demetri

An excommunication for the sack of Zara, that's right! So since they were excommunicate and cut off from the RCC then they were not technically RC. So the sack of New Rome was done by a bunch of former RCs. Isn't canon law great!
You're 'spinning' as a James Carvelle ballerina toy, c-r. This is silly and well addressed in a post below. Now you are an expert on Canon Law...

Pope Innocent III in point of fact DID forgive the actual Frankish crusaders before they even got to Constantinople- those who actually attacked Zara (Zadr) under contract to the Venetian merchants. He only left in place the excommunications against the Venetians traders. (The History of the Byzantine Empire- A.A. Vasiliev, Vol.II, pages 456-482). As to punishing anyone for the sacking of the City, he did nothing but protest that they did not go take Alexandria first and then Jerusalem as planned.
{ORTHODOXC has already given a good paragraph in response to my first post to your call for "sources" which you can insert here}

The Venetians and the crusaders were working in collaboration with the EOs who supported a rival claimant to the throne. Shouldn't someone be denouncing this 5th column?
The EOs ?????
You're really reaching here. There was NO vast "EO" conspiracy. The conspiring son of the deposed emperor (and his father) were closely and greedily related to western monarchs. Hardly a 'fifth column'. They both died in prison under the benelovent treatment of the new Latin goverment. Perhaps you need to do your own homework.

[I agree! A great gesture might be to return (to Mt Athos, away from the Turks) all the booty now at the Vatican. Actions would speak louder than...]

You can of course show us proof of ownership right? How do we know it belongs to you?
How 'clinton-esque' of you! In point of fact the booty looted was divided among the crusaders who placed it all through France, mostly in churches, the Republic of St. Mark (Vence) and the Latin abbots and clerics who participated in the pillaging. (Yes, even after 1054, there were still Latin bishops, churches, priests, and RCs in Constantinople.) It's hard to tell how much eventually ended up in the Vatican, especially the share of the Latin ecclesiastics.

The Byzantines could've stolen it themselves?
Pshaw!
I'll no longer have dialogue with you on this forum. You are not seriously pursuing anything here but argument. This exercise has yielded some rather strong anti-ecumenism reactions from me. Heretofore, I was of an mind to forget 1204, but thanks to your prodding me to read the history I will most likely give an unChristian reponse the next time an RC tells me to 'get over it'.

Demetri
 

Byzantino

Elder
Joined
Aug 9, 2003
Messages
353
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
45
Location
Melbourne, Australia
Perhaps Dollinger should have read Cardinal Newman more carefully.
I don't understand ???

The quote from Cardinal Newman is well documented besides being splashed all over the newspapers at the time. Is that what you're referring to?
 

sdcheung

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
1,325
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
48
Location
Middle Island, NY
didn't i tell you danny.
that reunion will only be possible when the vatican becomes orthodox.
that means a Bishop will have to come to the west and take the throne of peter.
 

sdcheung

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
1,325
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
48
Location
Middle Island, NY
+æ-ü+¦-â-ä+++¦+++«-é said:
Pshaw!
I'll no longer have dialogue with you on this forum. You are not seriously pursuing anything here but argument. This exercise has yielded some rather strong anti-ecumenism reactions from me. Heretofore, I was of an mind to forget 1204, but thanks to your prodding me to read the history I will most likely give an unChristian reponse the next time an RC tells me to 'get over it'.

Demetri
Thats the spirit.
Ferget Ecumenism..it's hopeless. better to be seperate. or to win Peters throne and turn it Orthodox.
 

Orthodoc

Archon
Joined
Oct 3, 2002
Messages
2,526
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
82
Location
USA
[Pope Innocent III in point of fact DID forgive the actual Frankish crusaders before they even got to Constantinople- those who actually attacked Zara (Zadr) under contract to the Venetian merchants. He only left in place the excommunications against the Venetians traders. (The History of the Byzantine Empire- A.A. Vasiliev, Vol.II, pages 456-482). As to punishing anyone for the sacking of the City, he did nothing but protest that they did not go take Alexandria first and then Jerusalem as planned.]

Exactly! If the crusaders were excommunicated prior to the sack of Constantinople as Carpo-Ruysn claims, then perhaps he can answer the following three questions for me -

1) Why did they still have Roman Catholic priests still with them who not only served Mass for them but gave them Absolution and Communion just prior to the beginning of the carnage?

2) Why did the Vatican and the Pope continue to accept bounty that it knew was stolen and looted for as period OF SIXTY YEARS?

3) Why did the Pope take advantage of an illegal act of some of his so called excommunicated subjects by setting up a Latin Patriarchate?

Inquiring minds would like to know.

======

Excerpt From 'The Sack Of Constantinople by Nicholas Cooke -


AFTER RECEIVING ABSOLUTION, the Crusaders attacked. Constantinople fell after three days of the final, furious attack by land and by sea. Once inside the walls, the Crusaders began an orgy of carnage, brutality and vandalism not seen in Europe since the barbarians invaded seven centuries earlier. No one was spared: not bishop, priest, nun, man, woman or child. Few women escaped being violated, whether at home, in the street, or in the convent. Fires were started throughout the city. The butchery ended only when the Crusaders were so tired that they no longer could lift their swords. Then began looting and profanation on a scale unparalleled in history. A mob rushed into Santa Sophia. With the Image of the Pantacrator looking down upon them from the great dome, they broke up the altar for its gold content, smashed the icons, threw the Holy Gifts to the floor, seized the church vessels for their Jewels, and tore mosaics and tapestries from the walls. Horses and mules were brought into the church the better to carry off the sacred vessels, gold, silver, and whatever else they could gather. Drunken soldiers drank from chalices and ate from patens while riding asses draped with priestly vestments. A mocking prostitute was placed on the Patriarch's chair to dance and sing obscene songs. This pattern of pilferage and desecration was repeated in churches, monasteries and palaces throughout the city. The tombs of the emperors were rifled, and all of the classical statues and monuments which had survived from ancient Greece and imperial Rome were destroyed. One writer wrote that never in history had so much beauty, so much superb craftsmanship been so wantonly destroyed in so short a space of time. What was not carried off was burned, smashed, melted down for its precious metal content, or stripped for its jewels.

After the killing, after the city had been subdued, there began a slow and steady removal of treasures out of the Orthodox temples and into the cathedrals, churches, monasteries, convents, cities and towns of Latin Europe. Some of these items had been venerated, cherished, and protected for centuries, others for a millennium. Now they were being carted away from over a hundred and fifty churches: altars, altar screens, tabernacles, antimins, icons, icon frames,
processional, pectoral and altar crosses, gold and silver chains, panagias, mitres, croziers, chalices, patens, star covers and spears, Gospels, Epistle books, ladles, church plate, censers, votive lights, relics, candelabra, epitaphia, fans, reliquaries, vestments, banners, manuscripts, miniatures, ivories, carvings, mosaics, thrones, tapestries, furniture and architectural items. Cartloads of gold and silver from Santa Sophia found their way into the Vatican treasury.
Constantinople had become the gold mine which supplied Latin Christendom.

The wealth was so great that the looting continued for sixty years.

==========

Orthodoc





3) [red]Fixed paragraphs to look pretty[/red]
 

sdcheung

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
1,325
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
48
Location
Middle Island, NY
ByzantineSerb said:
That's the spirit...though Christ doesn't seem to agree, according to Scripture.
Well he miscalculated what a mess the present Day Vatican Religion did to his Church.
 

ByzantineSerb

Sr. Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2004
Messages
171
Reaction score
0
Points
0
sdcheung said:
Well he miscalculated what a mess the present Day Vatican Religion did to his Church.
Present day? How has the present-day Vatican created a mess in Christ's Church (I'm assuming you mean the Orthodox Chuch)?

(Don't get me wrong, not a fan of false ecumenism).
 

prodromos

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Dec 3, 2002
Messages
1,463
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
57
Location
Back in OZ
sdcheung said:
Well he miscalculated what a mess the present Day Vatican Religion did to his Church.
Might I remind you that the Orthodox-Catholic* Discussion forum we are to "[blue]Discuss in charity[/blue] issues uniting and dividing the Orthodox Church and the Roman/Eastern Catholic churches."

I hope you will understand and not require another reminder.

John.
 

carpo-rusyn

Elder
Joined
May 8, 2003
Messages
383
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Philadelphia, Pa.
[Now you are an expert on Canon Law...]

Now I never claimed to be an expert on anything especially canon law, just drawing some conclusions.

[You're really reaching here. There was NO vast "EO" conspiracy]

I never said anything about a vast conspiracy just mentioned a 5th column. They way you describe it "the deposed emp and his father" makes it sound like it was just the two of them. So as per you I make it sound like a vast conspiracy and as per me you make it sound like it was two fellows out for mischief. I think the truth is somewhere in between, not quite a vast conspiracy and not just 2 fellows.

[(Yes, even after 1054, there were still Latin bishops, churches, priests, and RCs in Constantinople.)]

Oh come on! I am familiar with some Byzantine history.

[Heretofore, I was of an mind to forget 1204, but thanks to your prodding me to read the history I will most likely give an unChristian reponse the next time an RC tells me to 'get over it'.]

I never said in anyway that you should "get over it" nor did I imply it. We should never forget but we should forgive. We in the West forgive the misuse of the Crusaders of the 1st crusade by the Byzantine emperor. We forgive the Orthodox who served in the armies of the Turk at the walls of Vienna. We forgive the persecution of the Catholic Church of both rites under the Tsar in Russia then under the Communists and now under Mr Putin.

My apologies for raising within you such anti-ecumenical feelings. I in turn shall no longer dialogue with you so as not to raise these feelings again.

Carpo-Rusyn
 

Dan Lauffer

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2002
Messages
188
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
75
Location
Joliet, Illinois
Here is the full prayer that started this discussion. Perhaps there is more that needs to be said on topic.

January 16: Veneration of the chains of the holy Apostle Peter
Lord I Call...
Tone 4 To the special melody
Valiant Among Martyrs
Bound to the Lord, you were imprisoned in a dungeon.
Thus you bound falsehood, Apostle.
Therefore we honor you with love
and kiss your chains with faith.
From them we draw healing of body and salvation of our souls.
We fittingly praise you,
God-seer and conversor with the angels.
Those who are bound by ignorance,
receive understanding through you.
The peoples of the gentiles who first were scattered,
were shown to you in an image let down from on high
as a sheet containing every living creature.
Therefore, Apostle, every generation glorifies you,//
venerating the chains which you bore with diligence for Christ!
The One Whom you denied at His condemnation,
you hymned when He rose from the dead.
You preached Him to the ends of the earth, Apostle,
as the God and Man Who in His great goodness
entered into fellowship with mankind!
Therefore, we bless you with love, all-glorious Peter,//
venerating the chains which you bore with diligence for Christ!
Glory... Tone 6 (Byzantine)
Today Peter, the rock of faith,
the foundation of the church,
appoints his precious chains for the devotion of our souls.
Come and let us kiss them,
crowning him with songs of praise and chanting:
Rejoice, fervent champion of the faith,
for with ardent knowledge and great boldness
you confessed Christ, the Son of God!
Rejoice, joy of the universe,
keeper of the keys of the kingdom of heaven,
for you give grace to those who honor you with love
and venerate your precious chains with longing!
As you stand before the throne of Christ, the King of all,//
ever pray for us who celebrate your memory!
January 16: Veneration of the chains of the holy Apostle Peter
Apostikha
Glory... Tone 6
Peter, the rock of faith,
the fervent intercessor,
again lifts us up together for a spiritual feast,
setting before us his precious chains
as provision for a costly banquet
that our infirmities may be healed and our sorrows consoled,
and the storm-tossed ships of our life brought to harbor.
Come, let us kiss them, and entreat Christ Who glorified him,//
saying: By his prayers, O Christ, save our souls!
January 16: Veneration of the chains of the holy Apostle Peter
Troparion Tone 4
You came to us without leaving Rome
by the precious chains which you wore.
First-enthroned of the apostles
we bow down to them in faith and pray://
By your prayers to God grant us great mercy.
Kontakion Tone 2
Christ the rock, who greatly glorified the first among apostles,
calling him Peter, the rock of faith,
calls us now to honor the miracles wrought through Peter's chains,//
that He may grant us forgiveness of our sins.

 

sdcheung

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
1,325
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
48
Location
Middle Island, NY
Danny!..
Those are not PRAYERS.
Those are Kontakion, Troparia and Aposticha.
It's the special Theological/dogmatic pointers for the day to be chanted.

<duh>
 

sdcheung

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
1,325
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
48
Location
Middle Island, NY
I know alot more than you .
you come here.. after you check this ?
http://www.byzcath.org/cgibin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=4;t=001042

you intend to make trouble.

as for sh-t look at yourself in the mirror.
 

Dan Lauffer

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2002
Messages
188
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
75
Location
Joliet, Illinois
anastasios,

I think they let this nut case out too soon. The question I have is this, "Why must he be here?"

Dan Lauffer
 

Mor Ephrem

Hypatos
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Oct 3, 2002
Messages
36,445
Reaction score
341
Points
83
Age
41
Location
New York!
Website
www.orthodoxchristianity.net
Faith
Mercenary Freudianism
Jurisdiction
Texas Feminist Coptic
Dan and Sdcheung,

You've both been warned for using the language you used. I know you censored out one letter, but what really is the point of that when you are insulting each other? Cool it!
 

Dan Lauffer

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2002
Messages
188
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
75
Location
Joliet, Illinois
Mor,

Sd is crude and rude. I don't know why he is allowed on here. If you do not intend to take seriously some of the things he is saying then how do you suggest I respond to him? I guess I won't from now on.

Dan Lauffer
 

sdcheung

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
1,325
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
48
Location
Middle Island, NY
Crude and Rude?
I only respond expeditiously and in one two sentences.
the keyword is brevity.

How can I be crude and Rude when I only put down 2 sentences?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top