• Please remember: Pray for Ukraine in the Prayer forum; Share news in the Christian News section; Discuss religious implications in FFA: Religious Topics; Discuss political implications in Politics (and if you don't have access, PM me) Thank you! + Fr. George, Forum Administrator

"Traditional" Western-Rite Orthodoxy?

SubdeaconDavid

High Elder
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
504
Reaction score
2
Points
0
Location
Tasmania Australia
Website
orthodoxtasmania.blogspot.com
Facebook, that home of groups of all shades now has a "Traditional" Western Rite Orthodox group - a closed group which is odd for what should be a missionary endeavour of the Church.  In my own country with one surviving mission centered on St Petroc Monastery and Hieromonk Michael (Mansbridge-Wood) carrying the flag for traditional WR ers with a handful of active WR laymen, perhaps the missionary imperative of the paruchia impels efforts such as this new group.

If there is room for a  "Traditional" WR group, does that mean we have liberal Western-rite, and if so what do they look like?  What shape and identity does the Western-rite paruchia have?  Will it rise anew like the pheonix?


http://www.facebook.com/groups/41697446173/

Traditional Western Rite Orthodox
15 members
Closed Group
"The united parishes, using the Western Rite, shall bear the name "Western Orthodox". - 1936 Ukase, Russian Orthodox Church

This group is for those who are serving the Western rite in the canonical Orthodox Churches and supporters of the Western rite in the Orthodox Church.


http://www.orthodoxresurgence.com/
http://www.orthodoxresurgence.com/petroc
http://www.christminster.org/
http://www.westernorthodox.ca/
http://www.westernorthodox.com/
http://www.westernorthodox.com/stmark/
http://www.antiochian.org.nz/write/index.htm
http://www.standreworthodox.info/
http://www.russianorthodoxoklahoma.org/
http://www.stmichaelwhittier.org/dnn/
http://www.staugustinedenver.org/
http://www.stcolumbachurch.org/
http://www.stgregoryoc.org/
http://www.standreworthodox.com/
http://www.stmichaeloc.org/
http://www.emmanuelorthodox.org/
http://www.ststephensorthodox.org/
http://www.holyincarnation.org/
http://www.stvincentchurch.org/
http://www.saintpeterorthodox.org/
http://www.stpaulsorthodox.org/
http://www.holyapostlestyler.org/
http://www.st-benedict.org/
http://www.orthodoxlynchburg.org/
http://www.saintpatrickorthodox.org/
http://www.spokaneorthodox.com/
 

Shanghaiski

Merarches
Joined
Dec 26, 2009
Messages
8,257
Reaction score
342
Points
83
Age
43
Location
Wisconsin, USA
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
 

ialmisry

Strategos
Warned
Post Moderated
Joined
Aug 17, 2007
Messages
41,982
Reaction score
197
Points
63
Location
Chicago
SubdeaconDavid said:
Facebook, that home of groups of all shades now has a "Traditional" Western Rite Orthodox group - a closed group which is odd for what should be a missionary endeavour of the Church.  In my own country with one surviving mission centered on St Petroc Monastery and Hieromonk Michael (Mansbridge-Wood) carrying the flag for traditional WR ers with a handful of active WR laymen, perhaps the missionary imperative of the paruchia impels efforts such as this new group.

If there is room for a  "Traditional" WR group, does that mean we have liberal Western-rite, and if so what do they look like?  What shape and identity does the Western-rite paruchia have?  Will it rise anew like the pheonix?


http://www.facebook.com/groups/41697446173/

Traditional Western Rite Orthodox
15 members
Closed Group
"The united parishes, using the Western Rite, shall bear the name "Western Orthodox". - 1936 Ukase, Russian Orthodox Church

This group is for those who are serving the Western rite in the canonical Orthodox Churches and supporters of the Western rite in the Orthodox Church.


http://www.orthodoxresurgence.com/
http://www.orthodoxresurgence.com/petroc
http://www.christminster.org/
http://www.westernorthodox.ca/
http://www.westernorthodox.com/
http://www.westernorthodox.com/stmark/
http://www.antiochian.org.nz/write/index.htm
http://www.standreworthodox.info/
http://www.russianorthodoxoklahoma.org/
http://www.stmichaelwhittier.org/dnn/
http://www.staugustinedenver.org/
http://www.stcolumbachurch.org/
http://www.stgregoryoc.org/
http://www.standreworthodox.com/
http://www.stmichaeloc.org/
http://www.emmanuelorthodox.org/
http://www.ststephensorthodox.org/
http://www.holyincarnation.org/
http://www.stvincentchurch.org/
http://www.saintpeterorthodox.org/
http://www.stpaulsorthodox.org/
http://www.holyapostlestyler.org/
http://www.st-benedict.org/
http://www.orthodoxlynchburg.org/
http://www.saintpatrickorthodox.org/
http://www.spokaneorthodox.com/
Why not request to join, and ask?
 

ialmisry

Strategos
Warned
Post Moderated
Joined
Aug 17, 2007
Messages
41,982
Reaction score
197
Points
63
Location
Chicago
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
so they fit right in with the Eastern Orthodox in "diaspora."
 

Shanghaiski

Merarches
Joined
Dec 26, 2009
Messages
8,257
Reaction score
342
Points
83
Age
43
Location
Wisconsin, USA
ialmisry said:
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
so they fit right in with the Eastern Orthodox in "diaspora."
LOL. Bazinga!
 

Sleeper

OC.Net Guru
Joined
Oct 19, 2010
Messages
1,350
Reaction score
3
Points
0
Location
U.S.
My guess is that "traditional" Western Rite-ers are attempting (poorly) to distinguish themselves from those Western Rite Orthodox that use the Rites of St. Tikhon ("the Book of Common Prayer" rite from "the Anglicans") and St. Gregory (the "Tridentine" rite of "the Roman Catholics").

The great irony, of course, being that these (perfectly Orthodox in every way) rites were approved precisely because they were the living rites that were "traditioned" (Latin traditio "to transmit, to hand over, to give for safe-keeping") from generation to generation from Apostolic times to our own, via the two streams of catholic Christianity (Rome, and separated daughter Ecclesia Anglicana).

Those that forsake the received tradition in an attempt to re-create their own vision of "Western Orthodoxy" based on their favorite era/place/culture are the non-traditional ones.
 

Agabus

The user formerly known as Agabus
Joined
Apr 10, 2009
Messages
6,333
Reaction score
23
Points
38
Faith
Magnificat
Jurisdiction
La Virgen de Caridad del Cobre
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about how much lace is appropriate for vestments and then getting upset and forming their own groups.
Fixed that for you. ;-)

Just looking at the list of websites in that group description, there's a pretty wide range of "traditional" represented.

Probably just another Facebook WRO group, possibly the difference being that they aren't as friendly to canonically-questionable groups like the ECOF as others might be.
 

SubdeaconDavid

High Elder
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
504
Reaction score
2
Points
0
Location
Tasmania Australia
Website
orthodoxtasmania.blogspot.com
Sleeper said:
My guess is that "traditional" Western Rite-ers are attempting (poorly) to distinguish themselves from those Western Rite Orthodox that use the Rites of St. Tikhon ("the Book of Common Prayer" rite from "the Anglicans") and St. Gregory (the "Tridentine" rite of "the Roman Catholics").

The great irony, of course, being that these (perfectly Orthodox in every way) rites were approved precisely because they were the living rites that were "traditioned" (Latin traditio "to transmit, to hand over, to give for safe-keeping") from generation to generation from Apostolic times to our own, via the two streams of catholic Christianity (Rome, and separated daughter Ecclesia Anglicana).

Those that forsake the received tradition in an attempt to re-create their own vision of "Western Orthodoxy" based on their favorite era/place/culture are the non-traditional ones.
I think you are spot on.  The attempt to recreate "Celtic Orthodoxy" or the Sarum "use" is generally done in total disregard of the rest of the corpus of liturgical and spiritual norms of the Latin Church. It can be an exercise in taking DNA and trying to breathe life into what has long been in disuse, or worse, simply not fully known about.  It is an irony that the Western-rite do not use Latin anyway given that is was the principal language of the pre-Schism Church in the West.
 

ialmisry

Strategos
Warned
Post Moderated
Joined
Aug 17, 2007
Messages
41,982
Reaction score
197
Points
63
Location
Chicago
SubdeaconDavid said:
Sleeper said:
My guess is that "traditional" Western Rite-ers are attempting (poorly) to distinguish themselves from those Western Rite Orthodox that use the Rites of St. Tikhon ("the Book of Common Prayer" rite from "the Anglicans") and St. Gregory (the "Tridentine" rite of "the Roman Catholics").

The great irony, of course, being that these (perfectly Orthodox in every way) rites were approved precisely because they were the living rites that were "traditioned" (Latin traditio "to transmit, to hand over, to give for safe-keeping") from generation to generation from Apostolic times to our own, via the two streams of catholic Christianity (Rome, and separated daughter Ecclesia Anglicana).

Those that forsake the received tradition in an attempt to re-create their own vision of "Western Orthodoxy" based on their favorite era/place/culture are the non-traditional ones.
I think you are spot on.  The attempt to recreate "Celtic Orthodoxy" or the Sarum "use" is generally done in total disregard of the rest of the corpus of liturgical and spiritual norms of the Latin Church. It can be an exercise in taking DNA and trying to breathe life into what has long been in disuse, or worse, simply not fully known about.  It is an irony that the Western-rite do not use Latin anyway given that is was the principal language of the pre-Schism Church in the West.
why is that ironic?  SS. Cyril and Methodius abandoned Latin.
 

Schultz

Taxiarches
Joined
Oct 17, 2002
Messages
6,699
Reaction score
8
Points
38
Age
47
Location
BaltiCORE, MD
Website
www.theidlegossip.com
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
Bingo.  Having a closed group on facebook is akin to having a registration process/moderation staff on a messageboard.  It's a way to maintain control because, as we all know, there are all sorts of people with chips on their shoulders who like to push buttons for no reason other than their own perverse sense of entitlement.

If you're interested, ask to join. 
 

SubdeaconDavid

High Elder
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
504
Reaction score
2
Points
0
Location
Tasmania Australia
Website
orthodoxtasmania.blogspot.com
Schultz said:
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
Bingo.  Having a closed group on facebook is akin to having a registration process/moderation staff on a messageboard.  It's a way to maintain control because, as we all know, there are all sorts of people with chips on their shoulders who like to push buttons for no reason other than their own perverse sense of entitlement.

If you're interested, ask to join. 
Closed groups by their very nature generally do not welcome criticism, challenge or disagreement.  Otherwise they would be open.
 

mike

Protostrator
Joined
Sep 14, 2008
Messages
24,873
Reaction score
4
Points
0
Age
32
Location
Białystok / Warsaw
Faith
Christian
Jurisdiction
Diocese of Białystok and Gdańsk
SubdeaconDavid said:
Schultz said:
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
Bingo.  Having a closed group on facebook is akin to having a registration process/moderation staff on a messageboard.  It's a way to maintain control because, as we all know, there are all sorts of people with chips on their shoulders who like to push buttons for no reason other than their own perverse sense of entitlement.

If you're interested, ask to join.  
Closed groups by their very nature generally do not welcome criticism, challenge or disagreement.  Otherwise they would be open.
While joining each group on facebook you need to be accepted by the group's member (or admin).
 

Schultz

Taxiarches
Joined
Oct 17, 2002
Messages
6,699
Reaction score
8
Points
38
Age
47
Location
BaltiCORE, MD
Website
www.theidlegossip.com
SubdeaconDavid said:
Schultz said:
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
Bingo.  Having a closed group on facebook is akin to having a registration process/moderation staff on a messageboard.  It's a way to maintain control because, as we all know, there are all sorts of people with chips on their shoulders who like to push buttons for no reason other than their own perverse sense of entitlement.

If you're interested, ask to join. 
Closed groups by their very nature generally do not welcome criticism, challenge or disagreement.  Otherwise they would be open.
I think you misunderstand me.  

I'm a member of a number of closed groups on facebook (IIRC, the OC.net one is also closed for anti-info mining reasons).  We disagree all the time.  However, when some fool who has no actual interest in the group itself finds his way in (usually under false pretense) and starts attacking people, he is ushered out quickly.  Open groups on facebook are much more difficult to police, so to speak.  

It largely depends on how closed the closed group is.  If you have to go through some rigorous questioning in order to get in, then it's pretty insular.  But if the administrator(s) will accept anyone who asks to join, then it's pretty open regardless of it being "closed."
 

SubdeaconDavid

High Elder
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
504
Reaction score
2
Points
0
Location
Tasmania Australia
Website
orthodoxtasmania.blogspot.com
Michał Kalina said:
SubdeaconDavid said:
Schultz said:
Shanghaiski said:
I'm not quite sure what you're looking for, but Western Rite forums generally suffer from too many people arguing about too many things and then getting upset and forming their own groups. Often, many involved in the forums have never set foot in a Western Rite Orthodox service in their lives but believe they are eminently qualified to pontificate on all things related to Western Rite Orthodoxy. This attitude is probably the biggest factor keeping many potential, actual WRO persons from involving themselves in online discussions about WRO.
Bingo.  Having a closed group on facebook is akin to having a registration process/moderation staff on a messageboard.  It's a way to maintain control because, as we all know, there are all sorts of people with chips on their shoulders who like to push buttons for no reason other than their own perverse sense of entitlement.

If you're interested, ask to join.  
Closed groups by their very nature generally do not welcome criticism, challenge or disagreement.  Otherwise they would be open.
While joining each group on facebook you need to be accepted by the group's member (or admin).
Touche.
 

Shanghaiski

Merarches
Joined
Dec 26, 2009
Messages
8,257
Reaction score
342
Points
83
Age
43
Location
Wisconsin, USA
Maybe if one joined a group with a resolution NOT to criticize, since there is far too much criticism in WR anyway, it would go better. But, since people of whatever position in WRO online are often too busy bickering rather than praying and actually contributing to WRO in a constructive way, the WRO presence online is doomed to be much more than a cacaphony of squawking know-it-alls.
 

Agabus

The user formerly known as Agabus
Joined
Apr 10, 2009
Messages
6,333
Reaction score
23
Points
38
Faith
Magnificat
Jurisdiction
La Virgen de Caridad del Cobre
Shanghaiski said:
But, since people of whatever position in WRO online are often too busy bickering rather than praying and actually contributing to WRO in a constructive way, the WRO presence online is doomed to be much more than a cacaphony of squawking know-it-alls.
The online WRO groups seem to be divided between people who believe in it as a solid missionary endeavor and those who seem to be enamored with liturgy as theater, who at the first sign of a slightly cockeyed biretta start screaming, “UR DOING IT WRONG!”

I have an almost infinite amount of interest in the first group, especially in how they choose to baptize what they do in Orthodoxy (and let the reader understand, I think this is a good thing in some instances), but the presence of too many members of the second group prompts a quick click on the “X” in the upper left-hand side of my screen. Though I generally like the theological discussions, I pretty much exit the group as soon as the words "Sacred Heart" or "Corpus Christi" show up on my screen.

But to be fair, I feel the same way about some discussions that go on in ER groups.
 

Alpo

Merarches
Joined
Dec 9, 2007
Messages
9,878
Reaction score
3
Points
0
Faith
Mongol-Finnic Orthodox
Jurisdiction
Priestly Society of St. John Ireland
Western rite Orthodoxy is such a new phenomenon that there isn't an aura of tradition which settles many questions in Eastern rite discussions. So no wonder there are so many disagreements. It probably takes at least another century or so for these kind of things to settle down.
 

Carefree T

Jr. Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
Points
0
One of the parishes on that list is the one I found lacking in my thread in this forum, so I don't know what definition they might be giving to "traditional."
 
Top