Has anyone read Aristotle East and West: Metaphysics and the Division of Christendom / David Bradshaw? I was wondering what you thought about it if you did?
Yes; have read & own; definitely worth reading if you're interested in the E/E topic on an academic level. A great deal of it is dedicated to objective historiography of requisite concepts for which reason even those who find themselves at the end opposed to Bradshaw's point of view, e.g. those committed to ADS (as distinguished from DS as such) regard the work as valuable in its detailed exporation of the history of relevant ideas.
One caveat -unless you have a fair background in academic philosophy and perhaps historiography you won't find it a light read (I have a graduate school background in Phil & Theol)
One suggestion as a supplement if you want a broad variety of opinions on the work from scholars hailing from a variety of confessional backgrounds both agreeing and disagreeing, with replies to all by Bradshaw at the end, I would also recommend C. Athanasopoulos and C Schneider, eds.,
Divine Essence and Divine Energies: Ecumenical Reflections on the Presence of God in Eastern Orthodoxy. One thing clear enough an all sides in the wake of academic reception and/or reply to Bradshaw's work is, whether accepting or rejecting his conclusions, no serious academic treatment forthwith can really dispense with seriously engaging them.
